In 2018, the Ministry of Justice Law Commission was asked by government to review the process of extending or buying a lease and make it simpler, easier, quicker and more cost effective for leaseholders to achieve their goals.
One of the major issues will be to carefully balance enabling leaseholders to acquire or extend their lease whilst fairly compensating freeholder / landlords.
So, should leaseholders extend or buy their leases now – or wait until the Law Commission for England and Wales publish their conclusions?
Any leaseholder on a long lease is affected by leasehold enfranchisement legislation. The Law Commission says the enfranchisement law gives these leaseholders several important rights:
Current law surrounding this thorny issue can be difficult to unravel.
For instance, if there are fewer than 80 years left on a lease and a leaseholder wishes to extend, it will cost more to do so, but why?
Charles Oliver, Associate Director at Caxtons explains: "It seems obvious that extending a lease would automatically add value to a property. The Leasehold Reform Housing and Urban Development Act 1993 allows this to be done, but the freeholder / landlord is entitled to half of that increased value. The final calculation of cost is reached by valuing the property as it is (with, say, 79 years on the lease) for both freeholder and leaseholder, then valuing the property with an extended lease (eg: + 90 years = 169 years left) and adding half of the difference in value to the cost of extending the lease. This will be how much it will cost the leaseholder to extend the lease and is known as a Marriage Fee."
Charles gave one stark example of why it is important to take advice when venturing into leasehold law:
In 2006 a leaseholder unwisely agreed to a lease beginning at £1,000 per year and doubling every 10 years. When she asked the freeholder to extend her lease he asked for £120,000, even though the flat would only be worth £160,000 with a new longer lease.
He reduced his demand to £70,000 then, to avoid adverse publicity, to £40,000, which she reluctantly accepted. As the lease had more than 80 years to run there was no marriage value to add, but the price she paid was closer to that of a lease with around 30 years to run. For a flat with 93.8 years remaining, £10,000 should have been closer to the mark.
With the Law Commission's findings and recommendations still awaited, it is difficult to predict any outcome, or guess whether it would be advantageous to act now or, if there is time to spare (ie a few more than 80 years!), to wait for their conclusions before extending or even buying a lease.
As it is their stated aim to reduce the price payable by leaseholders to enfranchise, patience may in this case be a virtue. Whatever the result, it is still always advisable to engage an expert.
Charles' Simple Fact sheet:
Extending a lease on a leasehold property:
Collectively purchasing a freehold with other tenants:
Landlord and Tenant Act 1987
If there is no agreement over the price with either of the options set out, then it should be referred (within a six-month deadline) to First-Tier Tribunal – an independent adjudicator – who will fix terms.
Caxtons is delighted to renew its Patronage of Kent Invicta Chamber of Commerce (KICC) for the second time and now looks forward to its third year as a Patron.
David Gurton, Marketing & Business Development Director said "With the help of our Business Development Manager, Mandy Bearne, we have been able to take up opportunities and participate in many more events that KICC organises and hosts. This enhanced activity has ensured that we, directors and staff alike, now know many more people and businesses in both the Chamber and the Kent business community in general.
"The Chamber is well organised and pro-active and we have learnt a great deal whilst, hopefully, broadening the knowledge of other members by attending and participating in some of the varied networking events and Groups it runs. One such is the Economic Development Group, where by our involvement we are able to add value to our membership and expand understanding of our sector."
Even taking into account the precariousness of the property sector, Caxtons has had continued growth since
David continued "Through our Chamber membership and sponsorship we are delighted to be able to disseminate our professional opinion and expertise on the property sector to the wider membership. Graham Mitchell, our FD, recently wrote an article on how Brexit was impacting the sector and this was published on the KICC website – so we hope that other members were able to benefit from that insider information."
David Gurton, Mandy Bearne and Neil Chatterton proudly display Caxtons' 2019 KICC Patrons' certificate
Kent Excellence in Business Awards (KEiBA) 2019 is now open for entries and Caxtons is sponsoring the Start-Up of the Year category and would encourage you to visit http://keiba.co.uk/awardcategories/start-up-business-of-the-year/ where full details of how to enter can be found.
Marketing & Business Development Director, David Gurton, said ‘We are delighted to be involved with the 2019 Awards and pleased to be able to sponsor the Start-up of the Year category. We support and encourage local business wherever we can and we are particularly interested in this category and how new enterprises position themselves in their particular market-place.
"We wish all who enter the very best of luck and look forward to finding out about you and your business over the coming months."